ELDRLIVE
$ eldr --course money --day 07

Day 07 of 07

Automate the decisions you have already made

Everything so far was measurement and arithmetic. Today you convert it into a system that runs without your attention, and you write down in advance what you will do when markets fall.

Course
Money, with nothing to sell you
Minutes
40

Claim

Repeated decisions should be made once

Every month you decide again how much to save, you spend attention and you invite the mood of that particular Tuesday into a decision that should not depend on it.

So set the order once and let the bank execute it. A standing order on payday into the buffer until it is full, then into the wrapper from day 6, then whatever is left to spend freely with no guilt attached. The point of the system is not discipline. It is that the discipline is only needed on the day you set it up.

Action

Set the four transfers

Log into your bank and create automatic transfers dated the day after your salary arrives, in this order: minimum payments on all debt, the extra payment to the most expensive debt from day 3, the buffer contribution from day 4, the investment or pension contribution from day 6.

What is left in the current account is spending money. You do not need to track it, which is the entire reward for the work of the last six days. If the numbers do not fit, reduce the last transfer rather than skipping the first three, and note what the shortfall tells you about your fixed costs.

Claim

Write the policy before you need it

An investment policy statement is one page saying what you hold, why, how much goes in per month, and what you will do when the value falls. Institutions write one because it stops a committee from panicking. It works on individuals for the same reason.

The critical line is the one about falls, written now, while nothing is falling. Something like: if my investments drop 30%, I will continue the monthly transfer and I will not sell. A sentence you wrote in a calm month is the only argument available to you in a bad one.

Evidence

Why the fall clause is the whole document

The gap between what a fund returns and what its investors actually earn is measured annually by Morningstar in a study called Mind the Gap, which compares a fund time-weighted return with the money-weighted return its investors actually received. The investor figure comes out lower, and recent editions have put the shortfall at roughly one to one and a half percentage points a year. Check the current edition rather than quoting mine, because the figure moves and the method has been revised.

The mechanism is not mysterious. Money arrives after good years and leaves after bad ones, which is buying high and selling low, executed by ordinary people with the best intentions. You cannot fix that with information, because the people selling in month three of a crash are not short of information. You fix it by removing the decision, which is what automation and a pre-written policy do.

Example

Callum wrote his page in January and put one line in it: if the balance falls by more than 25%, I do nothing except check that the monthly transfer went through.

In April it fell 19% over three weeks. He read the line, which he had written in his own handwriting, and found it much harder to argue with than any article he could have read that week. He described the useful part as the date on the page: proof that a calmer version of him had already considered this exact situation and left instructions. He did not sell. Whether that turns out to be correct is not knowable yet, and it was still a decision made by the version of him best placed to make it.

Caution

Automation hides changes

A system that runs itself will keep running after it stops being right. Your rent goes up, a fee changes, your income drops, and the transfers carry on until the current account bounces.

So put one review in the calendar. Twice a year, fifteen minutes: check the transfers still fit your income, check the fees on the day 5 page, check the buffer target against your current fixed costs. Twice is enough. Men who review monthly end up tinkering, and tinkering with a long term position is the behavior the policy exists to prevent.

Aside

What this course cannot do for you

Everything in these seven days is mechanics, and mechanics have a ceiling. If your fixed costs exceed your income, no ordering of transfers fixes that, and the honest answer is that your problem is income or housing rather than budgeting. That is a harder problem and it deserves a different course, which is the career one.

There is also a version of this that goes too far: men who optimize fees to the third decimal while working a job they cannot stand. Money is a tool for buying a life you want. The arithmetic here is worth knowing because it stops a bad decision costing you a decade, not because the optimum is a moral goal.

Set your automatic transfers and write a one-page policy that includes what you will do if your investments fall 30%.

Transfers in order: debt minimums, extra to the most expensive debt, buffer, wrapper. Then the page: what you hold, monthly amount, the fall clause, and the two calendar dates for your fifteen minute review. Sign and date it. It is a promise from the calm version of you to the other one.

30 min

Day 07 — reading your progress.